zombie gathering

Discussion in 'Requests and Reports' started by sioutdoors, Sep 3, 2013.

  1. sioutdoors

    sioutdoors Well-Known Member VIP Creative Architect

    So I was wandering if letting zombies naturally funnel and gather to a villager before killing them counts as an advantage. Keeping the villager safe is the only thing that would be penned in so to speak. Zombies would be allowed to roam free.
     
  2. AwesomeGuy2010

    AwesomeGuy2010 Active Member

    I'm pretty sure it would.
     
  3. Legend9468

    Legend9468 Well-Known Member VIP

    I would imagine that it's the exact manner that you contain and kill them that would cause the issue. So long as it's a fair fight, I think it would be fine.
     
  4. sioutdoors

    sioutdoors Well-Known Member VIP Creative Architect

    They would migrate to the villager under their own power and in theory roam around in say a 20x20 room
     
  5. AwesomeGuy2010

    AwesomeGuy2010 Active Member

    Then that would kind of count as a mob grinder, if you then kill them.
     
  6. Legend9468

    Legend9468 Well-Known Member VIP

    I would think of it more as an arena, if it's on even ground.
     
  7. AwesomeGuy2010

    AwesomeGuy2010 Active Member

    I think that it would count as an arena if there was no bait, such as the villager. NikleKing's mob arena has no bait for mobs, they spawn naturally. I'm not too sure. But I still think that it would be a bit unfair because it's just a quick way to get xp.
     
  8. majestic_moose

    majestic_moose Well-Known Member VIP

    Provided there's nothing making it harder for them to attack you it's completely fine.
     
    thechooosen1 likes this.
  9. Legend9468

    Legend9468 Well-Known Member VIP

    One could argue that these mobs also spawn naturally; having bait is like having a theoretical wall to the arena, both prevent mobs from moving too far away.

    The villager to me is like a snow golem with aoe, all it does is draw them in, and serves no other purpose.
     
  10. AwesomeGuy2010

    AwesomeGuy2010 Active Member

    When you put it like that, I agree.
     
  11. Legend9468

    Legend9468 Well-Known Member VIP

    I can see where you're coming from as well. Well, Moose clarified it, so long as no advantage is given, then it's fine.
     
  12. sioutdoors

    sioutdoors Well-Known Member VIP Creative Architect

    No advantage will be given to me. The villager maybe lol thanks moose
     
  13. Pieman_Is_God

    Pieman_Is_God Well-Known Member VIP Creative Architect

    ban the villager
     
  14. sharqman

    sharqman Well-Known Member VIP

    [​IMG]
     
  15. QuietSea

    QuietSea Well-Known Member VIP

    [​IMG]
     
    Dynodamon, Pieman_Is_God and sharqman like this.